HomeRaw MaterialsCommodities‘Weather market’ lifts crop futures

‘Weather market’ lifts crop futures

By John Buckley March 2018
 

 

Crop weather issues in the US and South America – and potential for more from West Europe to Russia – saw grain and oilseed futures markets embark on a surprise bull run in the opening months of 2018.

On bellwether Chicago futures complex, wheat advanced by a remarkable 32 percent from the one-year lows it reached last December, recently trading seven-month highs. Maize and soybeans have also been up by as much as 15 percent each and soya meal by some 25 percent, to its most expensive for a couple of seasons.

It begged the question whether some of these markets had been oversold/undervalued at the tail end of last year when unusually large, even record levels of surplus stocks in some cases, seemed to promise a long-term bonanza of cheap inputs for consumers – albeit alongside pain for farmers struggling to break even in many producing areas.

Or did the rally, which spooked funds who earlier sold the markets down into a sudden rush of short-covering, whip up a lot of speculative froth that reasonable 2018 crops would blow away?

Looking at the principal factors, wheat"s stellar rise was mainly down to two. One was fear that reduced acreage and a freeze on top of a long drought, would slash the US 2018 autumn-sown crop. That outcome will become clearer in the weeks ahead as crops emerge from dormancy and the early harvests start in southern states around May.

The last appraisal from the US Department of Agriculture was for a crop not far off last year"s unusually small 47.4m tonnes. However, that followed a clear "surplus" crop of 62.8m in 2016, which left the US with a massive 32m tonne carryover to start the current 2017/18 season. Even after last year"s small crop, the US is still expected to finish 2017/18 with about 28m tonnes. That"s hardly a tight stock by historical comparison, equal to about 92 percent of US consumption needs or 51 percent of combined domestic and export use.

The second important factor has been a succession of rises in the export price of "Black Sea" (mainly Russian and Ukrainian) wheat during 2018 to date. That was underscored by recent purchases by the traditional top importer Egypt, paying Russian suppliers higher prices than for the past three years. Ukraine, which has shipped about four percent more wheat this year than last, has like Russia also been getting its best unit prices since late 2015.

The FSU price increases have been attributed to several factors – a response to the rising prices in Chicago, the Russia"s firming ruble currency, Ukraine looking well sold, so less able now to compete and not least, the usual loading/shipping problems Russia sees from harsh weather at this time of year.

Still, it"s slightly ironic that the main price depressant we highlighted in our last review – Russia"s ever-rising 2017 wheat crop estimate – should have turned out this way. One can only speculate that the CBOT price increases might have been even steeper, had Russia not been there as the dominant – and still relatively cheap – wheat export source.

It should be remembered that, even with the steep increases we have seen in demand for Russian wheat – exports doubling and its own domestic use up by one third in the past four years alone, Russia"s wheat market remains in clear surplus. The ending stock for the current season, for example is expected to increase by more than a quarter from last year"s 10m tonnes, putting it at two and a half times the level of two years ago. That provides quite a cushion against any unforeseen crop weather problems in the months ahead to the next Russian harvest.

At this stage, most observers expect this to be down by 5m to 10m tonnes. However, with a recent freeze apparently doing little damage and farmers taking advantage of cheaper fertiliser prices and applying more, a similar Russian crop to last year"s can"t be ruled out. Ukraine"s crop is meanwhile said to be in its best condition for four years, so should also be similar to last year"s.

Russia is expanding its transport and handling infrastructure and already seems to be exporting more grain the analysts expected a few months ago (seasonal shipments plus 43% on last year"s to date). Its winter sown crops have so far suffered no major frost damage. Ukraine"s crop is meanwhile said to be in its best condition for four years. And remember that last year"s crop was initially under-rated by 10/15m tonnes and more.

Among the other major wheat suppliers, Canada is now expected to expand acres for this year"s mainly spring-sown wheat crop. Australia might sow a bit less (harvest coming on stream towards the end of the year) but expects a La Nina climate event to bestow more rain, raising yields that suffered during drought in the past year. Even so, its currently forecast 23.7m tonne crop (last year 21.2m) may not prevent exports falling to a three-year low after its stocks were drawn upon to keep export sales going this season.

Having said that, some Australian wheat industry sources have been complaining that the cheap Russian and Ukrainian competition has made big inroads this season into their previously loyal Asian markets for milling wheat. (Discounts on Black Sea wheat versus Australian have recently ranged from US$25 to US$40 per tonne although some of that is down to lower quality.)

Argentina"s more recently-harvested wheat crop has turned out not far off the previous year"s at some 18m tonnes, enabling exports to jump from 12.3m to 14m tonnes and providing further cheap competition, not least for European exporters – another factor demanding some restraint from wheat bulls.

At the time of writing EU export volume is still running 20 percent under the level achieved this time last year with little immediate sign of an improvement. That has emboldened the USA, in its March world supply/demand estimates, to lop another 1m tonnes off its seasonal EU export forecast, adding that volume to ending stocks. (and it might be noted, the USDA sees EU exports falling by only 8.4% – so more cuts seem on the way). Along with the firm euro (a big factor in slow exports) this has kept the European market well to the rear of the Chicago-led wheat price advance.

EU crops also seem to have avoided major damage from the recent deep freeze, most areas getting adequate snow cover – although some problems with excessive rain and waterlogged fields could slow spring planting.

The US crop, as mentioned may not drop much, if at all, from last year"s level and, in any event, the difficulty the once-leading exporter is having finding adequate export markets (especially after the recent steep jump in its prices) amid the growing supply from alternative sources, must surely question whether it actually needs the big, usually surplus, crops it has sown in past years.

A key supply number for wheat is the global starting stock for the new season that begins around mid-2018. The USDA"s latest appraisal has raised these from 266m to 269m – even bigger than last year"s 253m and compared with the previous three-year range of 195/242m.

With crop problems yet to be proved by harvests, wheat prices may have got somewhat ahead of the fundamentals recently. Still, while nearby months have been backtracking toward mid-March, forward futures still point stubbornly "North" (plus 17% a year hence). That set-up may persist until we see what emerges from winter dormancy on both sides of the Atlantic and what spring and summer weather brings. There is also still the need to send an adequate price signal to farmers sowing this autumn.

 

Other recent developments

· The US crop most at risk from the weather – hard red winter wheat – supplied 43 percent of last year"s and 46 percent of 2016 total US wheat output;

· US high quality spring wheat has lagged the price rises amid ideas that the US, like Canada, will produce a bigger crop of this class this year;

· A quarter of the world wheat crop is exported. World wheat trade is edging up but at a far slower pace than for the past two seasons;

· The USDA annual Outlook Forum in February guessed US wheat planting for 2018 at a higher- than-expected 46.5m acres. Will more of those sowings be abandoned to grazing this year? Last year, less than 82 percent was gathered versus the previous two years" average closer to 87 percent. The smaller US spring wheat crop, yet to be sown, also faces drought issues in some key areas – a factor that needs to be watched;

· Canada"s expected larger wheat area partly reflects farmers turning away from less-valuable, pulses;

· The euro recently hit three-year highs against the US$, not helping slow exports;

· Indonesia has overtaken Egypt as the world"s top wheat importer;

· Russia has supplied a probable record 80 percent of Egyptian wheat import purchases this season, the rest going to Rumania.

 

Argentine drought shears soya surplus, boosts oilmeal costs

A drought in top soya meal exporter Argentina has lasted longer and done more damage than expected and along with some emergent problems in neighbouring Brazil, led to steep hikes in prices of soya and other oilmeals. Argentina provides about a third of global soya meal exports – which in turn make up almost three quarters of meal exports in total.

Recent appraisals by traders and local consultants have forecast Argentine crop losses of 7m to 10m tonnes, a few even more. USDA"s latest update went for a 7m cut to 47m tonnes – 9m less than it produced last year. That was offset by a 1m tonne increase to Brazil"s crop at 113m – yet that is almost certainly under-rated, with trade estimates ranging to 117m and above (despite some recent reports of rain delayed harvests in some areas and dry weather crimping yields in others).

The question mark overhanging Argentine supplies (one recent estimate was as low as 40m tonnes) combined with Brazilian farmers hoarding stocks for better prices – has resulted in a shift of importer buying interest to US beans and meal, helping to further the price rally.

Is the market over-reacting to the Argentine losses? Even with the latest production cut, the USDA is still forecasting Argentine 2017/18 seasonal crush will drop by less than 700,000 tonnes from last month"s forecast and a mere 300,000 tonnes from the previous season – so it can still export something close to last season"s 31m tonnes.

The reason for this, to which markets seem to be turning a blind eye, is the huge surplus stocks of soybeans the market has been carrying forward from one season to the next. The USDA"s last estimate of 2017/18 starting stocks is a record 96.7m tonnes, the lion"s share (36m) held in Argentina. And for 2017/18, USDA still has stocks finishing at a still massive 94m tonnes (albeit 4m less than it thought last month). Effectively, the soybean market has been carrying forward about 20-30m tonnes more beans than "normal."

The US has benefitted from Latin American supply issues, selling more soybeans and meal recently into export markets after a slow first half to its (Sep/Aug) marketing year. That, and the stimulation to US crush, has also contributed to the price rise in Chicago.

Not all fundamentals favour soya bulls. There has been much concern in the US that top importer China may retaliate against President Trump"s new US trade barriers by cutting back on soya imports from the US and favouring the Lat-Am suppliers instead (Brazil has already much enlarged its market share in China this season). Although China has recently started buying more beans from the US, that may be insurance against deeper Lat-Am crop problems emerging – which could be cancelled later if the latter supply proves adequate after all. If a trade war does erupt, the US would certainly feel cutbacks by its largest soya customer.

Further forward, the rally in soyabean and product prices may help ensure that the slightly larger US planted acreage many observers expect for 2018 does transpire. If the rally lasts long enough it may also help boost Latin American plantings in the autumn, especially Argentina"s as it tries to make up for this year"s crop and export sales losses.

Rapeseed/canolameal costs have been dragged up by the firm soya market, the Winnipeg futures market recently reaching its highest since November 2017. The rapeseed supply outlook is actually not bad this season, thanks to larger than expected Canadian and European crops more than meeting forecast consumption, helping to replenish previously tight end-season stocks. Early planting forecasts suggest another potential record Canadian canola crop in 2018. The Canadian government forecast a 4.5 percent increase to a new record 9.73m hectares which, even with a retreat in yields from last year"s highs could see a 400,000 tonne crop rise – plus bigger starting stocks than last year"s.

Prices on this year"s better-supplied European market have been slower to rise. Output increased more than expected last year in France, Poland and Rumania while more has been shipped into Europe from Ukraine"s bigger 2017 crop too. Europe"s mainly winter-sown crop is not seen changing much from last year"s. Ukraine"s 2018 winter-sown rapeseed crop is currently reported in mostly good/fair condition with local analysts looking for a 17 percent rise from bigger plantings while Russia is expected to sow more spring rape and less sunflower this year. Although EU sunflower sowingscould retreat somewhat this spring producing a slightly smaller crop, Ukraine should sow more, raising crop and export potential for the European market.

It"s interesting to note that, despite the recent Argentine soya crop losses, the USDA forecast for world production of oilmeals in total has actually been increased from 333.7m to 335.3m (versus last year"s 322.3m tonnes). As usual, the main increase in global meal consumption will be in soya.

 

Maize costs up with Lat-Am crop fears

Rising maize prices continue to draw strength from declining Latin American crop estimates – and not all the losses may yet be factored in. The USDA"s March estimates had Argentina"s crop at 36m tonnes compared with 39m last month and 42m at the turn of the year. Estimating Argentina"s carry-in stocks 4m tonnes higher than last year"s, USDA still sees Argentina boosting its exports from 23m to 25m tonnes. However, its customers are taking no chances on that, coming in for much larger quantities of US maize in the past month and helping to fuel Chicago-futures-led price jump to seven and a half-month highs.

It"s not only Argentina in trouble. Sowing of Brazil"s more export-oriented second or "Safrinha" crop has been held up by rain-delayed soya harvesting. The USDA projects Brazil"s total maize crop will drop to 94.5m from last year"s record 98.5m tonnes. However, this is still a pretty big crop and, combined with a much larger carryover from last year (14m versus the previous year"s under 7m tonnes) it is still expected to allow exports to increase from about 20m to some 31m tonnes. Those figures look highly negotiable however, if some of the Brazilian analysts much lower crop estimates prove correct (ranging down to 86.2/89.9m tonnes). Some Brazilian supplier caution is already evident. While their February exports of 1.25m tonnes were up by a hefty 157% on the year, they still halved from their a January peak.

Customers turning to US maize have now prompted the USDA to add a whopping 4.5m tonnes to its seasonal export forecast. That would be quite a turnaround after a slow first half to the season (running about 31% down recently).

USDA has also boosted its forecast for US ethanol consumption (now the largest outlet for the crop) by 1.27m tonnes to a new record 141.6m tonnes. That leaves US ending stocks 3.2m tonnes lower than thought earlier. It also helps reduce the world carryover stock of maize to a forecast 203m tonnes from last year"s near 230m. That"s not a small stock in historical terms but with consumption rising, the revision has helped stiffen prices.

Last year"s smaller Russian and Ukrainian corn crops have also reduced some of the competitive pressure in the global export market.

A supportive factor in the demand side, European maize consumption is expected to remain buoyant this season with imports reaching a four-year peak of 16m tonnes, making it the largest buyer in the world.

Forecasts that the US will again reduce planted acreage this spring are encouraging some analysts to mark up their price forecasts for latter 2018 although forward futures markets overall currently offer only premiums. Dealers also note China is planning to use a lot more bio-fuel and importing more corn ethanol, largely from the US. It is also taking in a lot more sorghum – the latter reinforcing trade ideas that its feed supplies may be less flush than earlier thought (USDA has also raised its Chinese maize import forecast by 1m tonnes recently). That said, China still has a huge maize surplus stock that it is trying to reduce to save costs. Whether this stock, much of it old, is fit for feed is unclear but more could conceivably go to its ethanol expansion.

Maize futures have also drawn strength from a weakening US dollar and ideas inflation could be rising fast enough to warrant more fund/speculative interest in commodities per se. Another factor has been the firm barley market, reaching its highest point in almost three years on lower world production and rising demand. Having been one of the more neglected crops by farmers in recent decades, barley"s global stocks are projected to drop to a 30-year low. As well as steady demand from top importer Saudi Arabia, China has emerged as a growing market for barley for both malt and ethanol production.

Next milestone for the coarse grain markets will be the USDA"s US planting intentions report on March 30 which will show how farmers are responding to a corn/soybean price ratio that has mainly favoured the latter in recent months.

NEXT POSTS

Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest news from industry

Newsletter Registration

DOWNLOAD OUR APP