August 2018
by John Buckley,

Six years ago, drought cut the Russian wheat crop by one third, reducing its exports by half. Russia had already moved into third place in the wheat supply league in the previous season so the effect on world markets was profound. World stocks were drawn down by some 20m tonnes.
Speculative funds piled in to the market, sensing opportunities to further the trend and reap bigprofits in the process. The bellwether CBOT wheat futures price rocketed from around US$6 closeto US$9.50 per bushel (almost $350/tonne), Paris milling wheat from around EU¤180 to EU¤270. Investment pundits again began to talk of higher prices becoming the new normal, making up foryears when agric commodities had failed to reflect broader inflationary trends.
It didn"t take long for a producer response around the world to shift the balance back to surplusand low prices. From the 2012 low point of about 658m tonnes, world wheat output went on a five-year expansionary spree culminating in last year"s record 758m while the carryover stock soared from 177m to 274m tonnes. Prices embarked on a four-year collapse to sub-US$4 lows and havesince fluctuated between that level and the mid-US$5"s.
The history lesson is pertinent in the light of this year"s similar Russian crop shortfall. But how does the present market situation compare in terms of implications for wheat prices?
Firstly, Russia"s crop. This is now thought to be down by between 22 percent (USDA) and 24 percent (Russian"s own agriculture ministry) at between 67m and 64.4m tonnes – i.e. about 18m tonnes less than last year"s.
However, the deficit is narrowed somewhat by the large stocks Russia is carrying into the newseason for a second year running – about 10m compared with the usual 5m or so normally.
Currently, the USDA thinks Russia can still export about 34m tonnes – 7m less than last season but still well above normal, in fact, its second-best performance ever.
But even a partial respite from Russian competition will be welcomed by several other exporting countries, not least the EU, USA, Australia, Argentina, Canada and Ukraine. The implied, less intense, rivalry for import custom may also give some relief to wheat prices that have nudged orgone below cost of production in several key regions in recent years. But this is no justification yetfor a major rally in the market of the sort seen in 2012.
Looking at the major producers" crop prospects for the 2018 harvests we see the traditional
top supplier, the USA, has recently raised its crop estimate from 49.7m to 51.2m tonnes, beating rather than falling below last year"s (lowest for many years) output. The key reason is a larger than expected spring wheat planted area and good weather favouring the current stellar condition rating for that crop. Latest estimates suggest production of the key hard red spring class is now expected to jump from 10.5m to almost 16m tonnes, the reason why springs have recently been leading market price weakness.
As mentioned in this column before, the US is also carrying forward large stocks from previous bumper years. 2017/18 started (in June in the US) with almost 30m tonnes, just 2m under their 2016/17 peak. Based on domestic use of around 31.5m and the US taking back some export market share (plus 5m at 27m tonnes), the USDA expects it to close this season in mid-2019 with almost 27m tonnes of wheat still on hand.
Crucially, about half of that wheat will be the main US breadwheat – hard red winter, also the class of wheat expected to see a production decline this year. A third, bearish consideration for the US market is early reporting of good harvest quality, fuelling ideas that new-crop grain can be used to blend up the usefulness of old-crop carry-in stocks.
The next piece of bearish news arriving on the market in the last few weeks has been a larger than expected Canadian crop estimate, now seen around 32.5m tonnes versus last year"s 30m. Canada"s 2018/19 season exports are currently seen rising by about 2m tonnes to around 24.5m.
More bullish news comes from Europe itself, where crop estimates have been shrinking recently following drought in Germany and earlier weather problems in France. The USDA cut its total wheat crop forecast recently from 149.4m to 145m tonnes compared with last year"s 151.6m.
The widely followed French analyst Strategie Grains has meanwhile reduced its own estimate for the soft wheat component by 8m to just 132m tonnes. However, the USDA
still expects the EU, amid less competition from Russia, to raise its exports this season from 23.3m to 27.5m tonnes (maybe a tadoptimistically). Getting to anything like that figure will meanreducing end-season stocks by about 4m tonnes to a relatively low 10.4m. That"s about 500,000 under the recent (2016/17) lowalthough not really a critically tight figure.
Another bullish factort is drought reducing Australia"s crop for the second year running to around 21/22m tonnes. Again, this is not a small crop by historical comparison (the sub-15m-tonne crops in some past weather-troubled years better fit thatdescription), but it along with relatively low stocks, it means a second season running of light Australian export competition.
Turning to the last two big players on the export market, Ukraine has also suffered some weather issues but seems to be coming out of them better than neighbouring Russia, expecting a crop of around 25/21.5m tonnes (last year 27m) and exports of 16.5m(17.5). Argentine meanwhile promises a larger probably closer to 20m than last year"s 18m tonnes, allowing exports of around 16.5m (16m).
Back in 2012, the world wheat market went into the Russian drought year with stocks of 198m tonnes – about 28 percent of consumption needs. By the following year that was down to 177m or 26 percent.
This season, the world market starts with 273.5m or almost 37percent. And is expected to finish with 261m or 35 percent – 4.2mtonnes" supply. That"s hardly a bullish number but it must be remembered that that largest share of this grain is not actually on the market but locked up in China"s strategic reserves, much of it old and probably of very dubious quality. Take away the Chinese component that leaves stocks at just 20 percent of global consumption (also excluding China) –or 2.4 months" supply.
Again, this in itself is no reason for a bull market but, from past experience it does seem to suggest some caution is needed by those engaged in the frequent sell-offs this market has seen in recent weeks.
After all, when all the crops are counted in for 2018/19, theglobal figure might well be lower still than the current 736mtonnes.
That said, demand for wheat does seem to be growing relatively slowly, averaging 1.6 percent per annum in recent years and expected to total just 0.9 percent this season. Growth is currently being led by "off-market" China which, at this point in time is notexpected to raise its imports significantly from the 3.5/4m tonnes(mainly higher quality wheat for blending) it has taken in recent years.
Moreover most of this growth is in feeds, using up some of the afore-mentioned vast reserve stocks. While one or two key importers like the top two (Indonesia and Egypt) are tending to take in more foreign wheat, far bigger reductions are being seen in domestic use of home-grown wheat in the EU (minus 2.5m) and Russia (down 6m tonnes).
To the backdrop of current crop Russian, European and Australian crop issues and consequent declines in global carryover stocks, forward futures markets continue to point tofirmer prices next year. The current premium over CBOT"s frontmonth (Sep) for the same position in 2019 is almost 11 percent.
EU wheat futures, despite having to tack and veer recently with an erratic US market, show a far more restrained forward structure than the CBOT, September 2019 prices more or less at par with current September and premiums of only around fourpercent going into first-half 2020. That may change if the EU –ion contrast to recent years – exports a bit more than expected and/or if Germany"s crop shortfall continues to require imports from other parts of the EU.
Another big US maize crop on the way?
CBOT corn futures have slumped by some 20 percent in recent weeks, bringing downward pressure to bear on global markets. The US has sown over 1m more acres than expected – still 1.1m less than last year but will likely harvest a larger proportion
of these. Good weather there has put crops in great shape –significantly better than at this time last year – suggesting theUSDA may be too light with its 174bu/acre yield forecast (versus last year"s 176.6).
So, while the Department has recently raised its crop forecast, from 356.6 to 361.5m tonnes, it could yet get closer to last year"s 371m. The US has been carrying large surplus stocks since its record crop of 364.8m in 2016 and enters the new season in September with a projected 51.5m.
The USDA is currently working on the basis that domestic demand will expand only slightly while exports will ease back
by 4.5m from this season"s (best for some years) 61m tonnes as crop recoveries pose more competition from South America. The 2017/18 season estimates of Brazilian and Argentine crops have been on the wane in the past month or two as drought and other weather issues ate into yields, Brazil"s 2018/19 crop forecast has also been shrinking recently but the region is still expected to hoist exports by some 5.5m tonnes or over 10 percent next season. The US will also meet more competition from Ukraine if it reaches the recent USDA crop forecast of 30m tonnes (last year 24.1m), implying about 4.5m tonnes more foreign sales. More supportive for prices, Russia"s crop estimate has been revised down by 3m to just 12m tonnes – so below last year"s 13.2m, implying a corresponding drop in export sales.
Global maize trade is seen expanding by about 5m tonnes next season as buyers in a number of countries respond to the cheaper prices, currently being led by the weaker CBOT market.
Globally, consumption is forecast to rise by 24.4m tonnes or 2.2 percent. China will account for some 10m tonnes of the increase by drawing on its huge reserve stocks. USDA has estimated these at almost 80m tonnes – about 40 percent of world surplus stocks. It sees China taking these down by 21m tonnes to 58.5m – roughly half the expected drop in world carryover stocks by the close of the marketing year (August 31 2019).
At 152m tonnes, world maize stocks will finish at a six-yearlow. In 2012/13 they equally 15.3 percent of consumption. By the close of 2018/19, stocks are estimated to cover just 13.9 percent of the coming season"s 1,094m tonne needs.
In the EU itself, maize production is seen similar to the levels of the past two years at 61.5m tonnes versus consumption growing from 76.6m to 78m. If imports into the bloc stay around last year"s 16m tonne-plus level, stocks here will likely drop another 2m tonnes or so to around 5m, their lowest for some years.
The prospect of stock depletion has not yet much impact on speculative support for maize futures, recently trading around their lowest since August last year.
However, the weakening pridce has encouraged "bargain- buying" from some key buyers, South Korea taking far more tyhan usual in the past month or so and Mexico, usually sharing top importer place with the EU, also an active buyer.
Futures markets suggest these low prices won"t last forever. The CBOT is showing miaze for delivery in September next yearabout 12 percent dearer than now and first quarter 2020 about 16 percent higher.
However, these forward premiums could be faded somewhat if the US crop turns out much bigger than expected or the Latin American producers make a bigger comeback. Or they could bejustified if demand continues to respond enthusiastically.
Rice record
The USDA"s latest forecast for world rice production in 2017/18 season to a new record high of 488m tonnes. Yet again, this will exceed consumption, raising stocks by about 7m tonnes to around 144m compared with only 128m just three years ago.
That should help keep rice prices – which have recently been fairly stable, under control, even as production eases slightly in 2018/19 (lower Chinese output, only partly offset by bigger crops in Thailand and Bangladesh).
Chinese demand cut curbs oilmeal strength
A less bullish mood has descended on the oilmeal/protein markets in recent weeks. Back in May, prices were jumping amid falling South American soyabean crops estimates and USattempts to fill those gaps by raising crush and exporting moremeal to Lat-Am customers.
In recent weeks, however, US markets have been spooked by President Trumps attempts to rebalance US trade with China, resulting in the latter imposing steep tariffs on US soybean imports. Many had hoped it was all bluff and counter-bluff. Now it is actually happening, the US soya industry has been wondering what it will do with another huge crop on the way, plus an expanding surplus stock.
On the encouraging side, US exports have not done so badly so far to other destinations, limiting the decline in total sales toaround five percent – despite a 20 percent-plus fall in demandfrom China (by far the USA"s top customer).
However, that has been achieved only by slashing prices. The extent of the price drop is shown on Chicago soya futures which have dropped by almost a quarter since the early days of the US trade skirmish with China. CBOT soya meal futures are also down by about 18-19 percent from levels ruling in May, despiteUS crushers boosting throughput to record levels to fill foreignorders that would normally met by top meal supplier, Argentina.
Because of the drought-reduced Argentine soybean crop, global production of oilseeds in total is estimated by the USDA to have dropped slightly in the 2017/18 marketing year now drawing toward its September close.
However, by drawing on large stocks, crushers have still been able to boost soya meal output by some 7.5m tonnes to a new record 233m, more or less matching the estimated rise in this season"s global demand.
Soya meal supplies are expected to grow faster in the 2018/19 season, assuming a huge rebound in Argentine soybeanproduction (arriving first half 2019) and, for the second yearrunning, large US and Brazilian crops. The current forecast for world output is 243m tonnes – 10m more than this season.
It"s not such a good year for sunflower seed or rapeseed crops,both originally expected to expand but after drought and other problems in Europe and the former Soviet countries, now seen down on last year"s.
However, by drawing on stocks, output of sunflower andrapeseed meals is at least expected to hold up at similar levels to this season"s. World oilmeal production in total is expected to reach about 343m tonnes, more or less matching consumption growth.
Will these low, soya-led, meal prices last? Futures markets suggest soybeans will cost about seven percent more one year hence, soya meal about the same as it does now. A potentially key bearish factor is China, attempting to adjust to its cutback in US soya bean imports. If this trade continues to fall victim to President Trump"s trade rebalancing act, the USDA thinks China"s soyabean imports will actually contract by 2m tonnes rather than rise by 6m as it thought earlier.
The USDA has also sliced almost 7m tonnes of its US soybean export forecast for next season. If all this comes to pass, the US will end up with 50 percent more soybean stocks next season (15.7m tonnes) and the world market will see carryover jump to a new record 98m tonnes. That implies continuing pressure on the CBOT soya complex and, despite the shortfalls in sun and rape crops, price restraint across the meal sector going into 2019.


































-scaled.jpg)














