HomeMachineryBioSecurity and Design in the Food and Feed Industry

BioSecurity and Design in the Food and Feed Industry

by Donald Hamm, Senior vice-President, Sales and Marketing, Zirconia Inc, USA

 

Safety and design have long been partnered together in the construction industry, and this pairing is the basis for many building codes that have been developed globally.

We have safety codes related to fire, physical safety of occupants and many more, but there has been little attention to biosafety in the design industry, with only a few exceptions up to now.

Most of these exceptions have been based around food chain production and health care, and are not the conversations many focus on, unless they are your specialisation.

Clearly, global awareness of this has become an issue and major changes are happening with the Covid-19 pandemic and the effect it has had across all industries.

What I am going to look at in this article is a shift in how we look at our projects and operations in terms of safety. When we talk about safety in the workplace, we need to make sure we include safety of the product, the customer, assets, employees and the environment. It is important that we not just assume the technology we have known and used in the past is the answer going forward. We need to look for new technology and new answers as our 'new normal' has shown what we have been doing is not enough.

Understanding contamination

First, we need to understand what we are talking about when we discuss biosecurity in regard to micro-organisms like bacteria, viruses and fungi.

For contamination to occur several things must be in place. The first is a transport method to move the organisms to a new surface and after air movement, that is usually us. Once a living organism is on a surface it needs several things to survive: food, water and habitat.

Anything that provides these three things is a host. Most porous surfaces can be hosts, and once organisms are on the surface, they can multiply, mutate, and more importantly transfer to other surfaces or people and repeat the cycle. Nonporous surfaces, though they often are not hosts, can still be transfer surfaces.

Sars-Covid 19 has been shown to survive on most surfaces for days; in some conditions as long as 64 days in colder environments1. These types of passive touch surfaces are common in the food manufacturing industry.

Unfortunately, they are known to extend the life of microorganisms, by capturing and holding them passively.

Feed at the start of the food chain

Many people look at the feed industry as the start of the food chain and the point at which problems first start. This can be seen in China where there is a strong drive to improve food safety and thus they have focused on the feed level to do this.

What does that mean? Due to the increased regulation on safety in the industry, where there were once 20,000 feedmills in China, there are now fewer than 6000 and downsizing will likely continue.

So, what can we do at each existing and new plant to address the need for better biosecurity?

Each operation is different and the needs for each will be different, but some basics are identifiable. While we must continue to focus on prevention of contamination entering our plants, the truth is, we have no way to guarantee complete success of no contamination entering our facilities.

We have trucks entering our sites from farms and other areas with wild and domesticated animals that can transport many microorganisms. We have people that come into our operations on a daily basis that may be exposed and transport all kinds of infections.

What we do not want is to let contaminations get in because we know how hard they can be to get out.

Teams from Kansas State University and Iowa State University did a test at a research facility where they prepared one batch of grain that was contaminated with Porcine Epidemic Diarrhea Virus (PEDV) and even after four clean batches and routine cleaning between batches, it was still present.

Machinery one meter away and surfaces up to three meters away were contaminated.

Eventually equipment was broken down, power washed, sanitised and the mill heated to 140 degrees for 48 hours to eliminate it.2 Who can afford to do this? Is there a better way to make these surfaces safer and less prone to contamination transfer?

Accepting that there is a problem

This is the problem we want to address here. We have traditionally put a majority of our effort, in clean room environments, into air handling and filtration which deals with the first part of the contamination cycle, which is transportation and is one of the key places we do need to address.

But what about contamination by contact or transfer?

Historically, we have turned to 'cleanable' surfaces such as low or non-porous substrates to reduce the habitat and food sources for microorganisms. But we are finding that this is not enough. Non-porous cleanable surfaces can still transfer virus's and other microorganisms and allow them to survive because they are 'passive,' they do not do anything to break the cycle of transportation.

Just being cleanable is not enough. Even our preferred surfaces of stainless steel and plastic, because of their durability and cleanability, allowed for longer survivability than on cardboard.3 So what do we do, now that we know our surfaces while being cleanable, are also potential hosts or transfer surfaces for the organisms we are trying to protect against and part of the cycle?

Creating active surfaces

As technology moves forward, we are going to need to look at options and technologies that are 'active' surfaces.

Traditionally, we have had passive surfaces like stainless steel that we can clean and then use disinfectants on to kill microorganisms. The problem is once the disinfectant is dry, the surface is again ready to be a host.

Once organisms are transferred to it, the cycle begins again. Some surfaces like copper and silver are naturally 'active' surfaces. We have known for centuries that these surfaces are 'healthier' and with the advent of science we now know why. They actively attack many of the microorganisms that come in contact with them and kill them.

Companies such as my own, Zirconia Inc, are developing coatings that are creating active surfaces. The technology was initially developed to make concrete and steel infrastructure more durable. The developers of the technology recognised that a lot of the failures of concrete and steel structures happened because of 'microbial corrosion.'

This is what destroys concrete in sewer systems and other damp environments. What they have done is realise that the technology they have to stop microbial corrosion, can also actively work on microorganisms that are wanting to use surfaces as hosts or transfer surfaces.

Their first line of products are designed for concrete and other porous surfaces and provide a four-layer defense against microorganisms. This defense makes treated surfaces 'Biologically Impervious,' or in another words, microorganisms cannot make it a host and survive on contact.

The first layer of the four-layer defense is a layer of 'nano swords' or nano sized rods that are many times smaller than the smallest of viruses. Microorganisms are attracted to the swords by their positive charge since the organism's membrane is negatively charged. Once contact has happened, the rod penetrates the membrane and releases its inherent static charge into the cell, destroying it.

The second layer of defense is the sealing nature of the coating. It reduces the level of porosity so low that organisms as well as food sources for the organisms, can't get past the surface and penetrate the surface. This means that it is very cleanable and durable. This in the past has been the one mechanism we have relied on for safety.

The third layer of defense is the same defense used by copper and silver, but in this case it is a non-toxic environmentally friendly element that is also oxidative. If a bacteria cell gets by a nano sword, the elements in our base coating will destroy the cells' membrane and keep the surface free from any further attack or damage.

The final defense is that the coating is photocatalytic. This means that when it is exposed to UV light, it takes the moisture in the air that is in contact with it and breaks it down to OH and O2 or essentially a natural bleach. Testing has shown that this coating system and its individual components are effective in stopping microbial and viral attack.4

Treating existing surfaces

Zirconia Inc is also releasing a line of products that will allow companies to treat existing transfer surfaces in the workplace made of a variety of different substrates to create an ultra-high performance, general maintenance surface protectant. This surface defense system is ideal for reducing environmental contamination and transfer of disease on both porous and non-porous surfaces.

The system includes a prime coat that seals and eliminates porosity while providing the ultimate base for the nano sword technology.

This is intended for high contact surfaces where temporary treatments are worn or wiped away with repeated cleaning and disinfecting. The second part of the system is a renewable application of nano swords that can be fogged onto the primed and other surfaces to turn them into long lasting 'active' surfaces to eliminate the host potential of building, equipment and even vehicle surfaces.

Other options for millers

Along with new surface technologies, there are a lot of other technologies being developed that we need to look at and consider as we look at biosecurity in the milling industry.

With air filtration and management, we have new filtration systems coming online each year. We now have ionization that can be tied into our air handling that forces particles to be dropped out of the airstream reducing the load on filter systems or even reducing the complexity of them.

We can look at UV C systems which can be used to kill microorganisms on surfaces, again helping stop the transfer cycle. While these are not safe around people and animals, they can be brought into systems safely and effectively.

What about air handling or mechanical systems that filter out larger particles, ionization in the air chambers that drop microorganisms to the surfaces and out of the air flow and then UV lighting that super activates coatings like Zirconia's to actively deal with all microorganisms that make it to the surface.

Best from the past

As an industry and society, we need to now be looking not at how we have built and created our operations in the past, but what is the best from that past that we can continue using and integrate with new technologies that will help us work on safety and security.

We need to look at safety compliance as not just another threshold to overcome or meet but make it a key part of our culture. We want to make sure our products are safe whether we are milling for human consumption or for animals that will end up in our food chain.

We need to make sure that our customers, employees, facilities and our environment is safe. This is the challenge I want to give us as an industry in the coming years as we look at how we are going to do business in this new 'normal.'

NEXT POSTS

Subscribe to our newsletter to get the latest news from industry

Newsletter Registration

DOWNLOAD OUR APP