Site icon Milling and Grain

Optimising wheat sourcing for sustainability and profitability

by Fabien Varagnac, Founder of Grains & Flours Insights and milling sector expert, France

Imagine a world where each kernel of wheat is utilised to its fullest potential, contributing to the most suitable flour quality at the best possible price. This isn’t a utopian vision—it’s a tangible goal within our reach. In the milling industry, there is no such thing as good or bad wheat; rather, there is the best wheat—or better yet, the best blend of wheat—for a specific application. By optimising our wheat sourcing and blending practices, we can enhance both sustainability and profitability across the industry.

The era of precision

We now live in an era where every aspect of production is scrutinised for optimisation, and the food value chain is no exception. As we strive to reduce humanity’s environmental footprint and build a more sustainable future, it’s essential to examine every detail of our operations. Fortunately, advances in technology are making it easier than ever to maximise operational efficiency.

Smart technologies

The integration of the Internet of Things (IoT) and big data analytics into milling operations has revolutionised our ability to monitor and manage wheat quality, mill performance, and customer feedback with unprecedented accuracy. These technologies empower us to gather precise data at every step of the process—from the wheat entering our mills to the flour leaving our production lines. With this information, coupled with machine learning and artificial intelligence (AI), we can better understand market needs and adjust our processes to meet them with pinpoint accuracy.

Achieving precision and efficiency

Millers around the world have always aimed to optimise their operations, but the tools now at our disposal allow for a level of precision and efficiency previously unattainable. By embracing these technologies, we can systematically refine wheat sourcing strategies, ensuring that each blend is perfectly suited to the specifics of each production line to achieve the desired flour specifications.

Less waste & more sustainability

Imagine the potential global impact if the entire milling sector adopted this approach—using only the right wheat for the right application. The ripple effects would be immense. By consistently meeting flour quality requirements, mills can significantly reduce unsold products, claims, and returns, leading to reduced waste. A reasonable one percent reduction in wasted flour could lower wheat consumption, cutting both raw material costs and carbon footprints by the same margin.

With IoT and sensor technologies, millers can monitor production streams closely, detecting unsuitable raw materials as they enter the system or during cleaning. This allows for early isolation of non-compliant material. During production, if flour specs deviate due to an issue like a broken or clogged mesh, real-time sensors can flag it instantly. This enables mills to segregate any off-spec flour before it leaves the plant, preventing non-compliant products from reaching customers, reducing waste and improving brand image.

Improving milling yield

By tailoring wheat blends to specific mill setups and continuously adjusting milling settings based on real-time monitoring of wheat characteristics can improve milling yields. A realistic 0.5 percent improvement could further reduce both costs and environmental impact.

This would be possible with the development of an AI-powered system that adjusts milling settings in real time based on IoT sensor feedback. For example, if your target ash content is set at 0.65 percent, mills often operate below this threshold to ensure compliance, resulting in variability between 0.60–0.65 percent. With AI and continuous monitoring, your mill can maintain precisely 0.65 percent, maximising yield while maintaining quality. This precision reduces over-compensation, ensuring that you get the most flour out of every kernel of wheat.

Optimising wheat grade usage

With more precise wheat blending, millers might be able to incorporate up to three percent of wheat currently classified as feed wheat into the milling grist without compromising quality. Feed wheat is typically US$10 per tonne cheaper than standard milling wheat, so this could lead to significant cost savings.

By leveraging data-driven systems for precise flour quality management, mills can reduce their reliance on high-quality wheat, which requires more fertilizer and impacts carbon footprint. If we reduce high-quality wheat consumption by 25 percent, we could lower the carbon footprint of five percent of global wheat production by 10 percent. Additionally, with a US$20 per tonne premium on high-quality wheat, mills could save substantially.

One way to achieve this is through AI-based feedback loops fed by customer data. For example, machine learning models based on customer feedback could reveal that a flour protein level of 12.1 percent meets customers’ baking requirement, even if mills initially believed 12.5 percent was necessary. This insight allows mills to reduce high-quality wheat usage and replace it with lower-quality grade or even feed wheat without compromising flour performance.

AI-driven wheat blend optimisation

This AI-based model could be extended for grist management, continuously adjusting wheat blends to hit target specifications while using the most cost-effective mix. For instance, if your target water absorption on the farinograph is 60 percent, you might currently blend 80 percent high-protein wheat with 20 percent lower-protein wheat to ensure your absorption stays between 60-61 percent. This buffer prevents shortfalls in four specs. With AI monitoring, the blend can be dynamically adjusted to hit exactly 60 percent, using just the right balance, potentially saving on higher-quality wheat usage and costs.

This holistic flour performance system, which links market demand with wheat specifications and incorporates all steps of the process, would become the ultimate tool to ensure you have the most optimised sourcing strategy.

A practical example

Consider a mill processing 1000 tonnes of wheat daily, operating 350 days a year, with standard 12.5 percent wheat price at US$300/tonne. Average grist is 80 percent 12.5 percent standard wheat and 20 percent 13.5 percent which cost an extra US$30/tonne.

Grist adjustment:

Improving efficiency:

This improved yield and reduced wasted flour would in turn reduce the total wheat consumption by 1.5 percent or 15 tonnes/day which equates to nine tonnes of CO₂e (assuming wheat production emits 600 kg CO₂e per tonne in average).

Impact on profitability:

Table 1 gives us a look at an average fixed cost of production of US$100/tonne, an initial operational yield of 79 percent and an average selling price of flour of US$550/tonne

Table 1

Looking at Table 2, see how the suggested improvements impact the margin and profitability of the mill.

Table 2

These adjustments would result in a daily margin increase of US$8050 (+16 percent) and a reduction of 12 tonnes of CO₂e, translating to US$2.8 million and 4200 tonnes of CO₂e annually for a single mill.

The global vision

Applied globally, these savings would be immense. With approximately 550 million tonnes of wheat consumed as food annually, this approach could save 8.25 million tonnes of wheat—more than UK’s annual wheat consumption for food—and reduce emissions by 6.6 million tonnes CO₂e, equivalent to 20 percent of the annual emissions of a country such as Switzerland.

Investing in digital transformation

For decision-makers, the return on investment (ROI) for adopting digital sourcing strategies is a critical consideration. While upfront costs for IoT sensors, AI-driven tools, and infrastructure upgrades may seem significant, the potential savings and productivity gains often offset these expenses quickly. As illustrated earlier significant margin increases can be expected, 16 percent in our example, offsetting investment within months.

Furthermore, service providers now deliver tailored tools for millers, allowing phased progressive implementation strategies. Mills can start small—such as by monitoring wheat quality—and gradually expand to full automation. This approach minimises disruption and reduces financial risk, making the transformation more manageable and scalable.

By adopting these technologies, millers not only enhance profitability but also future-proof their operations against fluctuating wheat markets and growing sustainability demands. With increasing access to affordable tools and expertise, even smaller mills can now compete with industry leaders in leveraging digital transformation.

A visionary outlook

The digitalisation of milling holds vast potential. Early adopters of these technologies will gain a competitive edge and lead the charge in creating a more sustainable and profitable industry. The journey will require commitment, investment, and a willingness to change. But for those who embrace it, the rewards—financial and environmental—will be substantial. The time to act is now. By fully embracing digital technologies in wheat sourcing, we can pave the way for a more sustainable and profitable future for the milling industry.

Published in the January 2025 issue of Milling and Grain.

Exit mobile version